Juridique en entreprise© m.jilapong-depositphotos

Adopted on 14 January, the law on the confidentiality of legal advice provided by corporate lawyers puts an end to decades of competitive disadvantage for French companies, say lawyers Noëlle Lenoir and Duncan Fairgrieve.

LES ÉCHOS article dated 12/02/2026

Noëlle Lenoir - Duncan Fairgrieve
The law ‘on the confidentiality of consultations with corporate lawyers,’ adopted on 14 January, better equips us to compete economically with other countries and their legal systems, as well as with companies themselves facing investigations by national and foreign agencies and national and transnational litigation.

Long awaited, this law establishes the principle of confidentiality for legal advice provided by lawyers within the companies where they work. In this respect, it sends a welcome signal to the business community at a difficult time when the French economy is in decline.

Amending the 1971 law on legal and judicial professions, the law provides that the opinions of corporate lawyers, who hold the required qualifications and are trained in ethical rules, are protected ‘in the context of civil, commercial or administrative proceedings or litigation’.

Notable exceptions
Unlike the work of solicitors, which is covered by professional secrecy, this protection is denied in three cases: in criminal matters, in tax matters and during audits conducted by the European Union authorities. These notable exceptions set France apart from other European Union countries and Anglo-Saxon countries.

But we can be pleased that the law guarantees, at least in part, following exemplary parliamentary work, the freedom of lawyers to assess the most appropriate legal course of action
for their company in an environment of legal, ethical, financial, political and economic risks.

Beyond the exceptions limiting the scope of the law, not only will the employer be able to decide to lift the confidentiality of a particular opinion, but this confidentiality may be challenged by any administrative authority or any claimant in a private dispute. The requested document will be placed under seal with a judicial officer: depending on whether it is a civil or commercial dispute or an administrative investigation, the president of the court or the liberty and detention judge will decide whether or not the document can be disclosed.

Towards the preservation of our economic sovereignty
Some may find these provisions convoluted. Certainly, but they are a step towards preserving our economic sovereignty. The legislator has finally decided to give French companies the means to face global competition and, incidentally, the lawfare to which they are subjected by foreign states, NGOs and competitors in France and abroad!

It should be remembered that the Legal Commission of Paris-Ile de France - Economic Capital in 2022 had recommended the transposition into French law of the ‘legal privilege’ granted to corporate lawyers and solicitors in England (and therefore in the United States before their independence) since a 16th-century case law (Berd v. Lovelace, 1577).

The concept of confidentiality of legal advice is inherent in common law. It is part of the fundamental right to quality legal advice: those seeking legal advice must be able to trust the person providing it, which means that the latter must be able to assess the issue at hand in complete freedom.

The Constitutional Council called upon
Members of Parliament referred the matter to the Constitutional Council, arguing that it was a breach of economic public order on the grounds that, in addition to overburdening judges (sic!), the confidentiality of corporate lawyers' opinions would hinder competition, whereas the aim of the law is to restore it.
There would also be a violation of the principle of equality, as the opinions of in-house lawyers would be better protected than consultations with solicitors, which are nevertheless covered by absolute professional secrecy...

Let us simply point out that the Constitutional Council, in 2016 with regard to non-financial reporting and in 2017 with regard to corporate vigilance plans, has shown concern for protecting ‘information relating to their industrial and commercial strategy’ and that French law has long incorporated the issue of confidentiality, in this case for the good cause of defending the quality and comprehensiveness of legal advice, which companies increasingly need.

Noëlle Lenoir is a solicitor and chair of the Legal Committee of ‘Paris/Ile de France – Capitale économique’.
Duncan Fairgrieve is a solicitor and member of the Legal Committee of ‘Paris/Ile de France – Capitale économique’.